Hospitals in New York
Medicare-certified hospitals from CMS Care Compare. The star rating is CMS's own summary of a hospital's quality measures - not our judgement, and not a rating of any individual clinician. Listed by star rating, then by the share of surveyed patients who would definitely recommend the hospital.
This selection
192hospitals
Average stars
2.77
of 136 rated
With emergency dept
160
83%
211
452
343
164
205
56n/r
Which of these CMS does not rate
Psychiatric
29 / 29
Critical Access Hospitals
15 / 21
Acute Care Hospitals
6 / 128
Rural Emergency Hospital
3 / 3
Childrens
1 / 1
By city
23 cities with more than one hospital| Hospital | CMS rating | Would recommend | Compared with the nation | ER |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hospital for Special Surgery New York · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 87% | 5 better | No |
| St Francis Hospital - the Heart Center Roslyn · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 85% | 4 worse 8 better | |
| Northwell Hospital Glen Cove Glen Cove · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 80% | 4 better | |
| Northern Westchester Hospital Mount Kisco · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 78% | 1 worse 3 better | |
| John T Mather Memorial Hospital of Port Jefferson Port Jefferson · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 77% | 5 better | |
| St Charles Hospital Port Jefferson · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 77% | 2 better | |
| White Plains Hospital Center White Plains · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 76% | 2 worse 6 better | |
| NYU Langone Hospitals New York · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 75% | 3 worse 21 better | |
| North Shore University Hospital Manhasset · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 74% | 4 worse 8 better | |
| Ns/Lij Hs Huntington Hospital Huntington · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 73% | 2 worse 7 better | |
| New York-Presbyterian Hospital New York · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 72% | 2 worse 13 better | |
| Hudson Valley Hospital Center Cortlandt Manor · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 71% | 1 worse 3 better | |
| Northport VA Medical Center Northport · Acute Care - Veterans Administration | 5/5 | 71% | No different | |
| Suny/Stony Brook University Hospital Stony Brook · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 70% | 2 worse 8 better | |
| Upstate New York VA Healthcare System (western Ny VA Healthcare System) Buffalo · Acute Care - Veterans Administration | 5/5 | 69% | 1 worse 2 better | |
| Lenox Hill Hospital New York · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 68% | 9 better | |
| Mercy Medical Center Rockville Centre · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 68% | 1 worse 3 better | |
| New York-Presbyterian/Queens Flushing · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 67% | 9 better | |
| St Catherine of Siena Hospital Smithtown · Acute Care Hospitals | 5/5 | 66% | 1 worse 4 better | |
| VA Hudson Valley Healthcare System Montrose · Acute Care - Veterans Administration | 5/5 | — | 2 better | No |
| Elizabethtown Community Hospital Elizabethtown · Critical Access Hospitals | 4/5 | 92% | No different | |
| Adirondack Medical Center - Saranac Lake Saranac Lake · Acute Care Hospitals | 4/5 | 83% | 1 worse 1 better | |
| Northern Dutchess Hospital Rhinebeck · Acute Care Hospitals | 4/5 | 83% | 3 better | |
| Community Memorial Hospital, INC Hamilton · Critical Access Hospitals | 4/5 | 82% | No different | |
| Cobleskill Regional Hospital Cobleskill · Critical Access Hospitals | 4/5 | 78% | 1 better | |
| Phelps Hospital Sleepy Hollow · Acute Care Hospitals | 4/5 | 72% | 2 better | |
| St Anthony Community Hospital Warwick · Acute Care Hospitals | 4/5 | 72% | 1 better | No |
| Bronx VA Medical Center Bronx · Acute Care - Veterans Administration | 4/5 | 71% | 1 worse | |
| Jones Memorial Hospital Wellsville · Acute Care Hospitals | 4/5 | 71% | 1 better | |
| Mount Sinai Hospital New York · Acute Care Hospitals | 4/5 | 69% | 3 worse 9 better | |
| Long Island Jewish Medical Center New Hyde Park · Acute Care Hospitals | 4/5 | 68% | 3 worse 10 better | |
| Plainview Hospital Plainview · Acute Care Hospitals | 4/5 | 68% | 5 better | |
| Garnet Health Medical Center Middletown · Acute Care Hospitals | 4/5 | 64% | 2 worse 4 better | |
| Mount Sinai West New York · Acute Care Hospitals | 4/5 | 62% | 3 worse 7 better | |
| Long Island Community Hospital Patchogue · Acute Care Hospitals | 4/5 | 52% | 1 worse 5 better | |
| VA New York Harbor Healthcare System - Brooklyn Brooklyn · Acute Care - Veterans Administration | 4/5 | — | 1 worse 2 better | |
| Syracuse VA Medical Center Syracuse · Acute Care - Veterans Administration | 3/5 | 80% | 2 worse | |
| Saratoga Hospital Saratoga Springs · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 77% | 3 worse | |
| Kenmore Mercy Hospital Kenmore · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 76% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| University Hospital S U N Y Health Science Center Syracuse · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 73% | 4 worse 3 better | |
| Highland Hospital Rochester · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 72% | 2 worse 2 better | |
| Vassar Brothers Medical Center Poughkeepsie · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 72% | 2 worse 8 better | |
| Corning Hospital Corning · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 71% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| Oswego Hospital Oswego · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 70% | 2 worse 2 better | |
| Putnam Hospital Center Carmel · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 70% | 1 better | |
| St James Hospital Hornell · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 70% | 2 worse | |
| Strong Memorial Hospital Rochester · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 69% | 3 worse 4 better | |
| Cayuga Medical Center at Ithaca Ithaca · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 67% | 3 worse 2 better | |
| Kaleida Health Buffalo · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 67% | 4 worse 5 better | |
| Sisters of Charity Hospital Buffalo · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 66% | 3 worse 3 better | |
| St John's Riverside Hospital Yonkers · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 66% | 3 worse 2 better | |
| Chsli St Joseph Hospital Bethpage · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 65% | 3 worse 2 better | |
| Montefiore Medical Center Bronx · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 65% | 4 worse 8 better | |
| Montefiore Mount Vernon Hospital Mount Vernon · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 65% | No different | |
| Nicholas H Noyes Memorial Hospital Dansville · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 65% | 1 worse | |
| Ns/Lij Hs Southside Hospital Bay Shore · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 65% | 3 worse 4 better | |
| Samaritan Hospital of Troy, New York Troy · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 65% | 3 better | |
| VA New York Harbor Healthcare System - Ny Div. New York · Acute Care - Veterans Administration | 3/5 | 65% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| Metropolitan Hospital Center New York · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 64% | 3 better | |
| St Marys Healthcare Amsterdam · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 64% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| Glens Falls Hospital Glens Falls · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 63% | 2 worse 4 better | |
| Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center West Islip · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 62% | 6 worse 4 better | |
| Mount Sinai South Nassau Oceanside · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 62% | 2 worse 5 better | |
| Ellis Hospital Schenectady · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 61% | 2 worse 3 better | |
| Aurelia Osborn Fox Memorial Hospital Oneonta · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 60% | 1 worse | |
| Our Lady of Lourdes Memorial Hospital, INC Binghamton · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 60% | 4 worse 1 better | |
| Staten Island University Hospital Staten Island · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 57% | 3 worse 6 better | |
| Good Samaritan Hospital of Suffern Suffern · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 56% | 4 worse 2 better | |
| Mount Sinai Beth Israel New York · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 56% | 4 worse 5 better | |
| Guthrie Cortland Regional Medical Center Cortland · Acute Care Hospitals | 3/5 | 54% | 2 worse 2 better | |
| Little Falls Hospital Little Falls · Critical Access Hospitals | 2/5 | 80% | 2 worse | |
| St Peter's Hospital Albany · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 77% | 3 worse 2 better | |
| F F Thompson Hospital Canandaigua · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 76% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| Clifton Springs Hospital and Clinic Clifton Springs · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 74% | 1 worse 1 better | |
| St Joseph's Hospital Health Center Syracuse · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 74% | 4 worse 2 better | |
| Chenango Memorial Hospital Norwich · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 73% | 2 worse | |
| Albany VA Medical Center Albany · Acute Care - Veterans Administration | 2/5 | 72% | 1 worse 1 better | |
| Oneida Health Hospital Oneida · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 72% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| Mount St. Mary's Hospital & Health Center Lewiston · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 70% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| Canton-Potsdam Hospital Potsdam · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 69% | 3 worse | |
| Crouse Hospital Syracuse · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 69% | 3 worse 4 better | |
| Peconic Bay Medical Center Riverhead · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 69% | 3 worse 3 better | |
| United Health Services Hospitals, INC Binghamton · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 68% | 5 worse 1 better | |
| Erie County Medical Center Buffalo · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 66% | 5 worse 2 better | |
| Newark-Wayne Community Hospital Newark · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 66% | 2 worse | |
| Queens Hospital Center Jamaica · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 66% | 1 worse 3 better | |
| Bellevue Hospital Center New York · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 65% | 2 worse 2 better | |
| Flushing Hospital Medical Center Flushing · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 64% | 1 worse 1 better | |
| Mercy Hospital of Buffalo Buffalo · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 64% | 2 worse 4 better | |
| Rome Memorial Hospital, INC Rome · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 64% | 2 worse | |
| Maimonides Medical Center Brooklyn · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 62% | 5 worse 6 better | |
| Unity Hospital Rochester · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 62% | 3 worse 4 better | |
| Wyckoff Heights Medical Center Brooklyn · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 62% | 1 worse 1 better | |
| Bassett Healthcare Cooperstown · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 61% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| Jacobi Medical Center Bronx · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 61% | 2 worse 2 better | |
| Montefiore St Luke's Cornwall Newburgh · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 60% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| Rochester General Hospital Rochester · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 60% | 5 worse 2 better | |
| South Brooklyn Health Brooklyn · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 60% | 3 worse 2 better | |
| The University of Vermont Health Network - Champl Plattsburgh · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 60% | 4 worse 2 better | |
| United Memorial Medical Center Batavia · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 60% | 1 worse | |
| Westchester Medical Center Valhalla · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 60% | 3 worse 4 better | |
| Elmhurst Hospital Center Elmhurst · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 59% | 3 better | |
| Samaritan Medical Center Watertown · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 59% | 1 worse 1 better | |
| Arnot Ogden Medical Center Elmira · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 58% | 3 worse 2 better | |
| Nyack Hospital Nyack · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 58% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| Brooklyn Hospital Center - Downtown Campus Brooklyn · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 57% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| Bon Secours Community Hospital Port Jervis · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 56% | 1 worse | |
| Nathan Littauer Hospital Gloversville · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 55% | 2 better | |
| Woodhull Medical & Mental Health Center Brooklyn · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 55% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| UPMC Chautauqua at Wca Jamestown · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 54% | No different | |
| Lincoln Medical & Mental Health Center Bronx · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 52% | 1 worse 2 better | |
| Geneva General Hospital Geneva · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 51% | 4 worse 1 better | |
| Auburn Community Hospital Auburn · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 50% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| Garnet Health Medical Center Catskills Harris · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 49% | 2 worse | |
| Harlem Hospital Center New York · Acute Care Hospitals | 2/5 | 49% | 2 worse 2 better | |
| Delaware Valley Hospital, INC Walton · Critical Access Hospitals | 1/5 | 86% | 1 worse | |
| Kings County Hospital Center Brooklyn · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 66% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| Suny/Downstate University Hospital of Brooklyn Brooklyn · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 64% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| Jamaica Hospital Medical Center Jamaica · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 63% | 3 worse 3 better | |
| Brooks-Tlc Hospital System, INC Dunkirk · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 61% | 1 worse | |
| Montefiore New Rochelle Hospital New Rochelle · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 60% | 3 worse 1 better | |
| Columbia Memorial Hospital Hudson · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 59% | 3 worse | |
| Albany Medical Center Hospital Albany · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 57% | 1 worse 4 better | |
| The University of Vermont Health Network-Alice Hy Malone · Critical Access Hospitals | 1/5 | 57% | 1 worse | |
| Bronxcare Hospital Center Bronx · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 56% | 3 worse | |
| St John's Episcopal Hospital at South Shore Far Rockaway · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 56% | 6 worse | |
| Niagara Falls Memorial Medical Center Niagara Falls · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 55% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| St Barnabas Hospital Bronx · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 55% | 2 worse 2 better | |
| Healthalliance Hospital Marys Avenue Campus Kingston · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 52% | 2 worse | |
| New York Community Hospital of Brooklyn, INC. Brooklyn · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 51% | 3 worse | |
| Wynn Hospital Utica · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 51% | 6 worse 2 better | |
| Nassau University Medical Center East Meadow · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 47% | 4 worse 2 better | |
| Richmond University Medical Center Staten Island · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 47% | 2 worse 1 better | |
| St Joseph's Medical Center Yonkers · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 46% | 2 worse | |
| Brookdale Hospital Medical Center Brooklyn · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 42% | 2 worse 3 better | |
| Olean General Hospital Olean · Acute Care Hospitals | 1/5 | 42% | 5 worse | |
| Keller ACH (West Point) West Point · Acute Care - Department of Defense | Not rated | 98% | Too few cases | |
| Westfield Memorial Hospital, INC Westfield · Acute Care Hospitals | Not rated | 91% | No different | |
| River Hospital Clinics Alexandria Bay · Critical Access Hospitals | Not rated | 89% | No different | |
| O'Connor Hospital Delhi · Critical Access Hospitals | Not rated | 88% | No different | |
| Garnet Health Medical Center Catskills Callicoon · Critical Access Hospitals | Not rated | 82% | Too few cases | |
| Margaretville Memorial Hospital Margaretville · Critical Access Hospitals | Not rated | 82% | No different | |
| Gouverneur Hospital Gouverneur · Critical Access Hospitals | Not rated | 76% | No different | |
| Bertrand Chaffee Hospital Springville · Acute Care Hospitals | Not rated | 70% | 1 worse | |
| Wyoming County Warsaw · Critical Access Hospitals | Not rated | 67% | Too few cases | |
| Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hospital of Yates Penn Yan · Critical Access Hospitals | Not rated | 65% | 1 better | |
| Schuyler Hospital Montour Falls · Critical Access Hospitals | Not rated | 63% | 1 worse | |
| Bath VA Medical Center Bath · Acute Care - Veterans Administration | Not rated | — | 1 better | No |
| Blythedale Children's Hospital Valhalla · Childrens | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Bronx Psychiatric Center Bronx · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Brunswick Hospital Center, INC. Amityville · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Brylin Hosp Buffalo · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Buffalo Psychiatric Center Buffalo · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Capital District Psych Center Albany · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Carthage Area Hospital, INC Carthage · Critical Access Hospitals | Not rated | — | Too few cases | |
| Carthage Area Hospital, INC Ogdensburg · Critical Access Hospitals | Not rated | — | Too few cases | |
| Claxton-Hepburn Medical Center Ogdensburg · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Clifton-Fine Hospital Star Lake · Rural Emergency Hospital | Not rated | — | Too few cases | |
| Creedmoor Psychiatric Center Queens Village · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Cuba Memorial Hospital, INC Cuba · Critical Access Hospitals | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Ellenville Regional Hospital Ellenville · Critical Access Hospitals | Not rated | — | 1 worse | |
| Elmira Psych Center Elmira · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Four Winds Katonah · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Four Winds of Saratoga Saratoga Springs · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Gracie Square Hosp New York · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Greater Binghamton Health Center Binghamton · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | |
| Helen Hayes Hospital West Haverstraw · Acute Care Hospitals | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Hutchings Psychiatric Ctr Syracuse · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | |
| Ira Davenport Memorial Hospital Bath · Rural Emergency Hospital | Not rated | — | Too few cases | |
| Kingsboro Psychiatric Hospital Brooklyn · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Kirby Forensic Psychiatric Center New York · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Lewis County General Hospital Lowville · Critical Access Hospitals | Not rated | — | Too few cases | |
| Manhattan Psychiatric Center New York · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Medina Memorial Hospital Medina · Critical Access Hospitals | Not rated | — | No different | |
| Mid Hudson Forensic Psychiatric Ctr New Hampton · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Mohawk Valley Psychiatric Center Utica · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | |
| New York City Childrens Psych Center Bellerose · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| New York State Psychiatric Institute New York · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Ny Eye and Ear Infirmary of Mount Sinai New York · Acute Care Hospitals | Not rated | — | No different | No |
| Pilgrim Psychiatric Center West Brentwood · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Rochester Psychiatric Center Rochester · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | |
| Rockland Children's Psychiatric Center Orangeburg · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | |
| Rockland Psych Ctr Orangeburg · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | |
| Sagamore Childrens Psychiatric Center Dix Hills · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Slhs Massena, INC Massena · Critical Access Hospitals | Not rated | — | Too few cases | |
| South Beach Psychiatric Center Staten Island · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| South Oaks Hosp Amityville · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| St Lawrence Psychiatric Center Ogdensburg · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Sunnyview Hospital and Rehabilitation Center Schenectady · Acute Care Hospitals | Not rated | — | No different | No |
| Unity Specialty Hospital Rochester · Acute Care Hospitals | Not rated | — | Too few cases | No |
| Western Ny Childrens Psychiatric Center West Seneca · Psychiatric | Not rated | — | Too few cases | |
| Westfield Memorial Hospital, INC Westfield · Rural Emergency Hospital | Not rated | — | Too few cases |